"You can usually count on the Oscars to be either good or bad, boring or surprising. This year's ceremony wasn't quite any of those things; instead, it was weird, thanks to the unsettling sense that we were watching a taped dress rehearsal full of inside jokes, presenters stumbling over their awkward banter, and dead air." New York Magazine.
"But there was a mixed reception for new hosts James Franco and Anne Hathaway who, despite their early admission that they were in place in order to lure a younger demographic, failed either to sufficiently amuse or charm with their combination of big-toothed enthusiasm (Hathaway) and lo-fi smirking (Franco). Appearances from former hosts Billy Crystal and, in one memorable sequence, the late Bob Hope, only served to highlight difficulties." - The Guardian
"Worst Oscars Ever? This was sizing up to be everything the Oscars are not supposed to be: clunky, amateurish, and pretty much lacking in actual entertainment value for those of us not picking up awards." - E-Online